Two collector bar slots per block
It is also well known that it is better to use two collector bar slots
per block instead of one. So for this fifth design change, the single
174 mm x 174 mm square collector bar has been replaced by two
87 mm wide x 174 mm high rectangular collector bars. The
average cast iron thickness on the two sides of the two collector
bars has been decreased to 11.5 mm which adds up to 46 mm of
cast iron as opposed to a total of 26 mm in the single collector bar
slot per block design. Figure 13 is presenting the resulting model
geometry. That it is still the same model topology but this time the
model represents 1/8 of a full cathode block instead of 1/4 as in all
the previous cases. Typically, the two collector bar slots are
located a bit closer to the block centerline than the two block
quarter points in order to have thicker carbon wings, but it is not
possible to test this case using the current model topology of
course.
Figure 14: Mesh of the two collector bar slots per block case
The model predicts 178 mV using the constant contact resistance
setup and 172 mV while using the temperature- and pressure-
dependent contact resistance setup.
So as far as the constant contact resistance version of the model is
concerned, replacing a single 174 mm x 174 mm collector bar by
two 87 mm x 174 mm should result in a reduction of 21 mV while
the variable contact resistance version of the model is predicting a
reduction of 20 mV. So the two versions of the models are in fairly
good agreement.
Conclusions
An ANSYS® version 12.0 based fully coupled TEM collector bar
slot design tool has been successfully developed and is now
available to the whole aluminium industry through GeniSim Inc.
The ANSYS® based APDL model is parametric, which means that
for a given model topology, it is possible almost instantaneously to
edit the APDL model input file to change the model geometry and
submit another run.
The finer mesh quarter block model presented here solves in only
around 5200 CPU seconds on a 64 bits dual core Intel Centrino T
9300 Cell Precision M6300 portable computer running ANSYS®
12.0 version. So this parametric ANSYS® based TEM collector bar
slot model is a very efficient tool to study alternative collector bar
and collector bar slot design.
A very quick design optimization study has revealed that it is
possible to reduce the cathode lining drop of a typical single
collector bar slot per block design having a square collector bar
section of 160 mm x 160 mm by 40 mV or about 19%. This is
done by keeping the same amount of carbon above the collector bar
by shifting to a double collector bar slots per block design. This
design is obtained by removing the cast iron above the bars with an
increase of the bar height while keeping the same collector bar slot
height and also reducing the cast iron thickness on the bar sides by
increasing the bar width while keeping the same slot width.
It was also demonstrated that changing the collector bar slot profile
design had some influence on the cathode lining drop. Performing
a true collector bar slot profile optimization study would have
required the development of a multitude of alternative model
topologies which was not done in the present study.
References
1.
Based Thermo-Electro-Mechanical Anode Stub Hole Design
Tool", in Proceedings of TMS Light Metals, (2010), 433-438.
2.
Reduction Cell Energy Balance Models to Assist Efforts to
Increase Lauralco's Smelter Productivity", Proceeding of the
ANSYS® 8th International Conference, volume 2, 2.233-2.240,
(1998).
3.
R. F. Boivin, P. Desclaux and J. P. Huni, "Cathode Collector
Bar Temperature and Current Pickup:", in Proceedings of TMS
Light Metals
, (1985), 625-635.
4.
M. Sorlie and H. Gran, "Cathode Collector Bar-to-Carbon
Contact Resistance", in Proceedings of TMS Light Metals,
(1992), 779-787.
5.
D. Richard, "Conception des tourillons d'anode en usage dans
une cuve de Hall-Héroult à l'aide de la méthode des éléments
finis", M.Sc. Thesis, Université Laval, Québec, Canada,
(2000).
6.
"Challenges in Stub Hole Optimization of cast iron rodded
anodes", in Proceedings of TMS Light Metals, (2009), 1067-
1072.